Viewing 40 of 3,056 rentals in New Suffolk
Tell us your dates, and we will find the most accurate rates and availability for you
Updating
Best Vacation Rentals in New Suffolk - Holiday Lettings - Cabins
13 Vacation rentals
from $1,037 / night
$7,259 / week
from $653 / night
$4,571 / week
from $688 / night
$4,816 / week
from $345 / night
$2,415 / week
from $290 / night
$2,030 / week
from $907 / night
$6,349 / week
from $1,000 / night
$7,000 / week
from $696 / night
$4,872 / week
from $2,000 / night
$14,000 / week
from $1,451 / night
$10,157 / week
from $510 / night
$3,570 / week
from $315 / night
$2,205 / week
from $440 / night
$3,080 / week
Great rentals within 20 miles that match your search
from $1,475 / night
$10,325 / week
from $1,525 / night
$10,675 / week
from $1,635 / night
$11,445 / week
Vacation cottage in Shelter Island Heights
Shelter Island Heights cottage
- 3 bedrooms
- 2 bathrooms
- sleeps 6
from $717 / night
$5,019 / week
from $405 / night
$2,835 / week
from $1,583 / night
$11,081 / week
from $1,381 / night
$9,667 / week
from $1,488 / night
$10,416 / week
from $1,255 / night
$8,785 / week
from $1,727 / night
$12,089 / week
from $1,925 / night
$13,475 / week
from $1,285 / night
$8,995 / week
from $632 / night
$4,424 / week
from $462 / night
$3,234 / week
from $1,235 / night
$8,645 / week
from $503 / night
$3,521 / week
from $945 / night
$6,615 / week
from $2,489 / night
$17,423 / week
from $523 / night
$3,661 / week
from $1,465 / night
$10,255 / week
from $1,637 / night
$11,459 / week
from $683 / night
$4,781 / week
from $1,253 / night
$8,771 / week
from $1,449 / night
$10,143 / week
from $405 / night
$2,835 / week
from $948 / night
$6,636 / week
from $1,671 / night
$11,697 / week